No Guarantees Theatrical Productions
Building a Broadway company's first credible digital presence
Client
No Guarantees Theatrical Productions
Role
Design & Product Strategy Partner
Timeline
16 weeks
Scope
Tech Stack
The Brief
When No Guarantees came to Boneyard, their public web presence was a Wix site — functional, but visually template-bound and structurally limited. For a company whose press line included Pulitzer winners and Nederlander Theatre bookings, the site read at the wrong tier. Navigation was shallow, the production portfolio wasn't doing the storytelling work it needed to, and there was no mobile touchpoint connecting audiences to the shows themselves. The existing tech stack (Wix, Bootstrap, React-via-platform) put a hard ceiling on what was designable and what was maintainable as the production slate grew. The inflection point was growth — both in the volume of productions and in the sophistication of the audiences and investors No Guarantees was now trying to reach. A Broadway company publishing original audience research on Gen Z theatergoing and launching Reg CF raises needs a digital presence that signals institutional credibility. A Wix template wasn't going to close that gap. The team also needed a mobile product that didn't exist yet: something that could deepen audience engagement show-by-show, across a rotating production slate. That combination — a full redesign, a net-new native app, and an internal CMS tool — required a partner who could hold design and product thinking together without fragmenting across multiple vendors.
What we did
For the web redesign, the priority was recalibrating the site's credibility tier without chasing a visual language that felt out of step with theater's mix of warmth and seriousness. We rebuilt the information architecture around the production slate as the core organizing principle — shows, press, and research each getting the space they needed rather than competing in a flat homepage grid. We deliberately held back from over-indexing on motion or visual complexity; the productions themselves are the content, and the design system needed to frame them, not compete with them. The migration away from Wix meant decisions about the new stack were design-forward — the CMS and component architecture were chosen to give the internal team real publishing flexibility without requiring design intervention for every update. The mobile app was a distinct product design effort. Each production — Hamlet, Fat Ham, Bad Cinderella — got its own content experience: cast bios, show times, play text, and interactive quizzes tuned to that production's audience. The design system across the app was built to accommodate productions with very different visual identities while keeping navigation and interaction patterns consistent show-to-show. Alongside the app, we designed the internal content management tool — a web interface that lets the No Guarantees team push updates to app content in real time. That tool was scoped tightly around the actual editorial tasks the team needed to do: no unnecessary complexity, fast enough to use between production meetings.
The outcome
No Guarantees now has a public web presence that reads at the level of what they're actually producing — a site that can absorb a new show announcement, a research report, or a venue press release without looking like it's straining against its own structure. The migration off Wix removed the design ceiling that had been limiting what the site could credibly do as the company's slate expanded. The companion app gives audiences a named, production-specific destination that didn't exist before — a place to go deeper on the shows, not just look up ticket times. And because the internal management tool puts content control in the No Guarantees team's hands, the app stays current without creating a development bottleneck every time a cast change or new quiz needs to go live. The platform now scales with the company rather than requiring a rebuild every time the production slate grows.
Part 01
What we inherited
The existing site was a Wix build — navigable, but template-constrained in a way that showed. For a company with a Pulitzer credit and active Broadway bookings, the visual tier was misaligned. Press coverage was buried, productions didn't have room to breathe, and there was no mobile presence at all.
Part 02
Rethinking the architecture
Before touching visuals, we rebuilt the site's information structure around the production slate. Shows, press, and research each became first-class sections rather than competing items on a flat homepage. The goal was a structure that could absorb a Nederlander announcement or a Reg CF launch without requiring a redesign.
Part 03
A case for restraint
We chose a grounded visual system over anything that leaned heavily on motion or expressive type. Broadway sits in a category where the productions themselves are the spectacle — the site's job is to frame them credibly. A quieter design system earns more trust here than a loud one.
Part 04
The companion app concept
No Guarantees needed a mobile product that could deepen audience engagement show-by-show — not a generic theater app, but something production-specific. We designed the app to give each show its own content experience: cast bios, show times, play text, and quizzes, initially built out for Hamlet, Fat Ham, and Bad Cinderella.
Part 05
One system, three productions
Fat Ham and Hamlet live in very different visual registers. The app design system had to flex across productions with distinct identities while keeping navigation and interaction patterns consistent enough that a returning user always knows where they are. That constraint shaped every component decision.
Part 06
Quizzes and cast pages
The per-production content went beyond showtimes. Cast information pages, interactive quizzes tied to the specific show, and play content gave audiences a reason to open the app after buying a ticket — not just before. The interaction design was kept lightweight so content, not UI, stayed center.
Part 07
The internal CMS tool
Alongside the public-facing app, we designed a web-based management interface so the No Guarantees team could push content updates in real time — new cast additions, quiz edits, schedule changes — without touching code or filing a ticket. The tool was scoped tightly around the actual tasks the team needed to do, nothing more.
Part 08
Migration off Wix
Moving off the old platform wasn't just a visual upgrade — it removed a structural ceiling. The new web stack was chosen to give the internal team publishing flexibility without design intervention for routine updates, and to support a production slate that adds shows on its own schedule.
Part 09
A platform that scales
The deliverable across both workstreams was a platform that grows with No Guarantees rather than requiring a rebuild every time the slate changes. New productions slot into the app. Press and research live in a structure built to hold more. The company's digital presence now reads at the level of what it's actually producing.
Next Project
Nav